It is no secret that the Modern philosophers as far back as Hobbes and Locke viewed dampening religious zeal and removing it from the public realm as a cornerstone of their cultural project. But I place much of the blame on 21st century America's resistance to organized religion on people like Dolan, whose resistance to gay rights and other social issues places them at odds with modernity.
The head of the Bishop's committee on religious liberty, William Lori, exhorted his flock to stand up for the rights of their religion -- most notably, the right to deny gay couples their right to adopt children. In fact, Lori claims that laws which make it illegal for state funded adoption agencies to deny gay parents adoption rights infringes on their religious liberty, and forces Catholic agencies into insolvency. Apparently, these agencies would rather help no one, and let scores of children remain in foster care, than to let gay couples adopt them.
Focusing on issues like gay adoption not only shows overt prejudice but also demonstrates seriously twisted priorities. In the words of the liberal Catholic, John Gehring, "The bishops speak in hushed tones when it comes to poverty and economic justice issues, and use a big megaphone when it comes to abortion and religious liberty issues."
When unemployment remains above 9 percent and with poverty rates at tragically high levels, how can anyone take seriously people who claim that the real ills our country face result from gays being allowed to adopt. These skewed priorities are what is moving religion back into the sacristy, as the Bishops' concerns become less relevant to everyday people.
So the next time Dolan and Lori claim to be victims of progressive culture, they shouldn't blame others. Instead of looking to the left for reasons why religion is becoming irrelevant to many Americans, they should stare straight ahead into a mirror.